Which will save you more green when you're washing your clothes -- gas or electric?

iStockphoto/Thinkstock

adAfterSmallInset

Gas vs. Electric: Which dryer is more energy-efficient?

Buying a new household appliance is usually a long-term investment, whether you're replacing an old unit or setting up a home for the first time. Why not take advantage of the occasion to buy the most energy-efficient products you can? Before you buy a clothes dryer, though, you need to understand the difference between the two types that are most commonly available: gas and electric.

Both types of dryers function similarly -- air is drawn into the dryer, passes through a heating coil, warms the clothes inside, collects moisture, and is vented out. Gas dryers use gas to create the heat, and electric dryers use electricity. Both types use an electric fan to distribute the heat. Even though both types require a steady stream of electricity, gas models are slightly more efficient.

According to the Consumer Energy Center, the clothes dryer (whichever type you have) is the second most energy-hungry appliance in the house -- only the refrigerator uses more power. Dryers are measured by a standard called the energy factor, which measures pounds of clothes per kilowatt hour of electricity. (This standard is also used in a similar application: measuring the power usage of water heaters.) The energy factor's ultimate cost depends on current electricity rates, but the Consumer Energy Center says the average household will spend about $85 per year to keep its dryer juiced.

Shopping for a clothes dryer might be a little off-putting -- many models are available in both gas and electric versions, and unlike nearly every other type of appliance at your chosen electronics or home store, clothes dryers don't display those ubiquitous Energy Star placards. Energy Star is a voluntary label that spotlights the most efficient appliances in each class, but since all dryers have similar energy requirements, they don't qualify for the program. For that same reason, clothes dryers also are exempt from displaying the EnergyGuide placard (which is usually a requirement).

Don't stop reading here, though -- we'll discuss more differences between gas and electric dryers, as well as some energy-conserving alternatives.

 

Check to see if you have a gas line if you're considering a gas dryer.

iStockphoto/Thinkstock

adAfterSmallInset

Gas Dryers and Energy Efficiency

When you're researching your new dryer, you can expect most gas models to have an energy factor of about 2.67 and above. This is a rather high energy factor, but it's a little less than electric models. That difference ends up being about 50 percent less power per load (and therefore save you more on your electricity bill) [source: Consumer Energy Center]. So, gas dryers usually cost more up front, but they save money in the long run.

A slightly higher up-front price tag in exchange for money and energy savings for years to come? It sounds easy, but unfortunately, your decision might not be that simple. If your laundry area isn't equipped for a gas dryer, the upgrade will be a pricey investment (if it's even possible at all). First, gas dryers require a gas line; if you don't already have one, you're probably out of luck, since they're dangerous and expensive to install in an occupied residence. If you've got one, though, that gas line will provide a potent source of heat.

Gas dryers also require a vent to expel the moisture removed from your clothes. They remove condensation in the form of hot steam, which must be quickly and safely moved outside the residential area. In most places, building codes require this vent to end up outdoors to prevent any danger from gas by-products. Unfortunately, condo and apartment dwellers might not be able to install gas dryers unless a suitable venting solution -- outdoors or to a common HVAC system -- has already been incorporated.

If your place doesn't have the right hookups, though, a gas dryer might not be for you. On the next page, we'll discuss alternative drying options.

Green Drying

Appliance manufacturers have responded to the need (and the profit opportunity) for clothes dryers that can pose as a bit more green. High-end gas and electric models boast energy-efficient features such as sensors that shut off the machine when clothes are dry, and cool-down (or perma-press) cycles that finish up nearly-dry clothes with a tumble through unheated air. If you don't want to splurge on a top-dollar model, or you prefer to keep your older-but-perfectly-good appliances as long as possible, you can still take advantage of a few power-saving tips. Use an extended spin cycle, if your washer has one. It'll shake more water out of your clothes, requiring less heat to dry. Remove lint from your dryer's filter regularly, since clogged filters can make the dryer use up to 30 percent more electricity [source: Consumer Energy Center]. And save up a few loads of laundry to do on the same day -- if the dryer runs consecutive loads, it'll require less work to stay warm.

adAfterSmallInset

Electric Dryers and Energy Efficiency

The energy factor of electric dryers starts at 3.01, slightly higher than their gas counterparts, but the difference is such that each load of laundry will cost about twice as much as a gas dryer would cost. Electric dryer models cost a little less up front, though, and they're often easier and less expensive to install.

If you choose an electric dryer, you're spared the inconvenience of venting, which makes electric dryers a convenient choice in multi-family and small homes. (All compact and combination units, especially popular with apartment-dwellers, are electric.) Electric units most commonly remove moisture through condensation; that is, once the hot air collects moisture, it's cooled, and the resulting water vapor ends up in a tank or tray that must be emptied periodically.

However, this extra power use requires an upgrade in infrastructure. Electric dryers use a 240-volt outlet, twice the standard household current, so if you don't have one, you'll need to hire an electrician to hook you up.

Sound complicated? The simplest solution might not be an option for space-constrained urban dwellers, but if you've got some yard space to your name, put nature to work. Despite some drawbacks (like dependency on the season and weather, or the restrictions of finicky homeowners' associations) using a clothesline is the least expensive, most energy-efficient way to dry clothes. The sun and wind are extremely effective -- no 240-volt outlet or steam vents necessary. Your clothes will also stay in better condition.

Keep reading for more household tips and energy conservation pearls of wisdom.

Lots More Information

adLastPage

Sources

  • Consumer Energy Center. "Clothes Dryers -- Energy Choices at the Home." 2010. (Sept. 12, 2010)http://www.consumerenergycenter.org/home/appliances/dryers.html
  • Consumer Energy Center. "Energy Star Appliances - Energy Choices at the Home." 2010. (Sept. 12, 2010)http://www.consumerenergycenter.org/home/appliances/energystar.html
  • HomeDepot.com. "Buying Guides: Dryers (Gas and Electric)." (Sept. 16, 2010)http://www.homedepot.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/ContentView?catalogId=&langId=-1&pn=Dryers_Electric&storeId=10051
  • McGrath, Jane. "How can you wash and dry clothes with steam?" TLC Home. (Sept. 12, 2010)http://tlc.howstuffworks.com/home/wash-and-dry-with-steam2.htm
  • Nice, Karim. "How Clothes Dryers Work." HowStuffWorks. (Sept. 12, 2010)http://tlc.howstuffworks.com/home/dryer.htm
  • Ronca, Debra. "Can the right appliance save me money?" TLC Home. (Sept. 12, 2010)http://tlc.howstuffworks.com/home/right-appliance-save-me-money.htm